Learning to Write

Fosse QuoteFosse_Angel

Let Me Get This Out of Your Way

Intriguing stumble-upon. Β Clearing an old flash drive for my daughter I ran across this – texts from my first and only public reading – featuring art by George Ferrandi and Laura Barbuto, which occurred in an interactive reading space with many assistants and much assistance a couple years ago. Β Seemed like it belonged in this space.

space_ferrandi

  1. Sitting at table amid a narrative hum. No one speaks.

“Getting it Out of the Way: A Response”

(texts by Nathan Filbert; art/images Laura Barbuto/George Ferrandi)

 

Without Criteria: Laramie

Picasso - don quixote

Laramie shoots and kills.Β  Laramie loves and captures.Β  Catches and release.

Riding along the ridge, singing, swearing, singing.Β  This journey’s a long time coming.

The need to get away.Β  For autonomy.Β  To be self-called.Β  To begin after all of this and that.Β  Recall and resound.Β  Taking stock.

He’s always been this way – a little undomesticated.Β  A touch of untamed wild.Β  Never finding a place.Β  Never quite belonging.

Boundaries forged by relation and response (-ability) all forwarding to limits, cages, toward constraints or restraint he can not abide.Β  Each vocation or program, discipline or field, replete with vocabularies and methods, praxis and behaviors misfitting to degrees he finds it hard to accept.Β  A β€˜lone wolf,’ β€˜self-made man,’ a patent failure or β€˜with no name.’  Renegade?

He rides.Β  The shuffling flanks feel heavy under him, providing awareness of his own weight.Β  Considers Alias, and thinks how both do not belong.Β  How adamant and vehement he himself cries freedom, how Alias skinnies and wriggles past the gates.

How neither could ever be said to have β€˜succeeded.’  How both (in his mind) would never have failed.Β  How neither and both are alike.Β  Neither and both are so different.Β  Neither and both alive.

Rides on.Β  Too old for all this but he’ll camp out tonight.Β  To prove to himself that he’s old bothΒ and wild.Β  Yet.Β  That he aches to be tamed and untame.Β  Yearns to belong, independently.Β  The want for a self that is selfless.Β  The urge for a course without banks.

Laramie wants to be world, alive.Β  Wants to be fertile and virile, viral, untrained.Β  Wants claimed and confessed-for, wants derided and praised.

β€œWe’re the renegade scholars,” sometimes he wouldΒ say, β€œlearning the lingo and undoing like acid its heart.”  β€œWe master and tell of its weakness, expert novitiates in all.”  β€œWe unwind and unravel.Β  Travel and root.Β  We are rhizome,” he says, β€œdrawn out from anywhere.Β  We absorb and vituperate, ingest and expel.”

He rides, and he rides, in love with the muscling flanks.Β  The wind tearing through hair and beard, blistering cheeks, stinging his eyes.Β  There are tears.Β  Laramie swallows.Β  The sorrow and joy are one.Β  Life and its death copulating…heaving and sweating, oily and dry to the bone.Β  He is brittle.

Laramie is needing to stop, and he feels it.Β  His body is singing – pain tells.Β  Time is ripe.Β  There’s an end.Β  It is coming.Β  Unrolling his pack…here it goes…

Ends – the Means to Get There; or, Laramie says “OFF.”

ON OFF image

I drill. I devour.

Kafka, Blanchot, Derrida, Bartleby.Β  Pessoa, Nietzsche, Jabes, Beckett.

Into the absence of hope.

Of language.

Of body.

I drill and I devour.

Myself.

Vitality.

Capacity.

I try to think my end(s).

I want to get there.

I would like to make it to the end.

I would like to make the end.

I think.Β  I serve.Β  I love.Β  I ask.

I care.Β  I touch.Β  I say.Β  I listen.

I am not fulfilling.

I am never quite what is wanted.

I have never been β€œright” for a situation.

I am a person who tries very hard to be what is wanted.

I am a person who tries very hard to offer what is β€œgood”.

How would I know?

– what is wanted?

– what is good?

I do not.

I am incapable.

But I DO know:

I AM NOT THAT.

(do not) BE HERE NOW.

simply : do not.

β€œI would prefer not to.”

β€œI will not”

No reason.

No anwer.

We are just humans.

Animals.

Purposeless.

Pointless.

Without reason(s).

Without meaning(s).

Without.

Still we go on

(for now)

Still we keep on

Still

On

On

On

OFF

(he said, said Laramie to Alias. β€œOFF.”  He said, said Laramie to Alias.Β  And then he was gone.Β  Really.Β  Gone.)

Sometimes it happens this way.

Sometimes.

OFF

Simply, over.

[Often, in my case and experience.Β  They come, they go.Β  There is a rush of blood to the brain and the loins.Β  There is something I assume the others refer to as β€œhope,” – some reason to live, to go on, to pertain.Β  Then OFF.Β  Binary.Β  Digital.Β  Technology.Β  Culture.Β  Beings-in-relation.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Lights.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Progress.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Will.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Love.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Value.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Need.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Mood.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Everything binary.Β  Irrational.Β  Abstract.Β  Illogical.Β  Happenings, events, occurrences.Β  ON/OFF.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Life.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Life.Β  ON/OFF.Β  Life.Β  ON/OFF.

Life.

ON/OFF.

We are coming to an end.

I am coming to end.

We each come, to end.

The End.

 

 

Laramie Poeticus

Laramie liked to think himself a poet.Β  One attuned, natural, native to his world(s).Β  He liked to think he had unique feelings, perhaps an β€œinsight,” an acute attention – that maybe he saw just a little bit more than others saw.Β  And was able to say so.

A farmer-cowboy type from the upper Midwest, he played a lot of sports and performed muscled labor – at times enjoying the solitude of pasture rides and the company of large mammals.Β  He felt a β€œcare,” not sure for what, suspect he’d call it a kind of β€œconnection” – with crop growth, animals, the waters and the skies.Β  And felt he could say so.Β  And he could sing.Β  Musician, farmer, cowboy, son.Β  Husband, scientist, laboring man.Β  Father, friend, and β€œpoet” (he might say).Β  Laramie James Backstagger, dearly known to Alias.

β€œWhen you’re making it – forming words or music – do you feel somehow that you’re β€˜getting it’?” Alias might ask, as they ambled the fields chopping at thistles, remedying fence.Β  β€œDo words add to experience or just chop it up?Β  Diminish?Β  Reduce?” Alias chimed.

Laramie would go silent, plodding along, smelling and listening.Β  Looking.

At times they’d play basketball, tennis (this was all in their youth, Alias having blown out his knees at the pigskin).Β  And careful.

They both went on to cities: education, enlightenment, the β€˜experience’ of cultural promises.Β  They still had their debts to pay.

β€œI mean, when you β€˜see’ it, or β€˜hear’ it, are immersed – it’s not seeing or hearing or sensing – am I right? It’s just being – and then – ?” Alias prodded, β€œand then – what happens?”  β€œYou hear language, or find it or forge it, dream times or β€˜intuit,’ you consider ways you’d be able to MARK it – note it down (letters or score) – recount or recreate it – even extend or rescind it – and that all seems like media to me: communication: expression or history or talk…but reduced.Β  Reduced to what YOU can comprise or compose – not the β€˜same’ as the moments, trembling in the web, and borrowing, borrowing, borrowing – from the wind and the trees, weather and bees, family and learning, working and friends – and our culture! – all funneled and cored to some desiccated fraction of bone – eviscerated – β€˜HERE LIES LARAMIE’S TAKE’: some words or an etude or painting.Β  Even action.Β  Even sowing or reaping or pruning or care…’HERE LIES LARAMIE’S TAKE’ – wow!Β  Really?!Β  Amazing!Β  One moment made this?!Β  AND WHAT CARES?Β  WHAT MATTERS?Β  WHAT PURPOSE OR POINT, BENEFIT OR CONSEQUENCE…the next β€˜now’?!”

Alias could go on and on like this. Β Often doing what he’d just described or decried.

And Laramie’d slow, maybe stop, often sit, and stare out.Β  Have a smoke (he didn’t smoke, but pretended – his children and wife didn’t like it).Β  And Alias would drink and get wiser.Β  A little calmer and sad.Β  And all might go quiet, save the world always humming.

Laramie Backstagger sighed.

β€œWell?Β  Whadda ya think?” challenged Alias – β€œhow is it for you when you speak, feel or sing?”

And how would he know, ailing Laramie?Β  Been too many years of conflicting events and results and mixed feelings.Β  Too many miles that worked out without working, or failed for the working too much.Β  β€œI’m uncertain,” he said, β€œI’m uncertain.”  β€œBut you’re pushing at something in me.”

By now Alias was off on his own like a mammal, had concocted a scent for to trail.Β  Maybe the ache was for sharing the thing they were sharing: agreement.Β  Maybe to get through the whole business at once, simultaneously.Β  Maybe to notΒ be divided and different or just pieces of things – to be doubled or tripled or multiple?Β  Harlequin – pieceworked and patched, back then and now and some future.Β  An assemblage, a collage wanting melding.

β€œAll uncertain,” Laramie said.Β  β€œI can’t know, just I do it and feelings will follow.Β  New ones.Β  Pains from smashed understandings, joys from promising starts, aches at the poorness I lend them – but something goes on, carries forth – it don’t end with the birds and the breeze.Β  The words have it too, and the voices.Β  The shapes and the meanings and lines.Β  Even tones.Β  It goes on, both the good and the ill, and I’m part, or it seems such.”

β€œHow β€˜bout you?” Laramie wants to know.Β  β€œWhy do you carry on and keep blabbing,” he taunts.

β€œJust to borrow,” Harlequin murmurs.Β  β€œJust to steal.”  β€œTo have something to say.Β  To keep silent.Β  To wish that it might carry on.”  β€œIt’s what we’ve got, all these things.Β  Try as I might, I don’t know what else to do, and at times feel compelled, god dammit.Β  Like Foucault or Blanchot or Spinoza.Β  Or Buddha or Christ, Kafka or little Jane,” (little Jane was the crazy old lady – lived two miles from the Backstagger’s farm – she’d sparkle to company no matter the cause and just cackle and croon – mixing nonsense and stories, opinions and facts, just talking and talking and talking.Β  No one knew if it ceased when they left, it never stopped within range of the hearing).

β€œI hear you” said Laramie, β€œI see.”  To which Alias always replied β€œBut you don’t – I don’t know that.Β  Have no method of saying it’s true.”  And they’d keepΒ walking on…toward night.

 

Ecriture – ‘I write’ – Why write?

ecstasy - st therese

Nihilism – Melancholy – Language – Silence

No meaning (no matter)

Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Sorrow (fail again)

Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Speak (try again)

Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β  Β Silence (fail better?)

A darkness.Β  Immersion.Β  This life.Β  The living it.Β  Ever to and toward a pointless death (again, another, also).Β  To be.Β  To be (as human).Β  To wish.Β  To wish for otherwise(s).Β  To IMAGINE.

Music.Β  Vision.Β  Feeling.Β  Sound ~ Meaning.

I am (one) capable of crafting a fine sentence.

And so – ?

She sings, birdlike, wind-like, tree-like, animal, a hiss of land.

He cavorts shapes, models, architecture – opportunities of space – perhaps, perhaps not yet, perhaps becoming.Β  In progress…

That one strikes a chord: says.Β  Plays.Β  Possible resonance.Β  Possible possible.Β  Manufacturing potential.

I am forlorn.Β  Shorn.Β  Shriven, stricken, silent.

Working within the arranging of existing things – without vision – mathematician with its figures, logician with axioms, linguist syllabic syntagms.Β  Utilizing signs.Β  Pre-existing me – letters and language – scratches and symbols – touches and sights – emotions and thoughts and exhaust…

Minima Philologica

β€œVery little…almost nothing”

A signal, a marking, a shape inferring sound

(above some hopeful/hopeless void)

And yet…

Organism ~ orgasm.Β  Biologically an entity capable of immersive ecstasy.Β  What can, might, has the potential to be – la petite mort – weakening of consciousness, swoon, a likening unto death.Β  This life.Β  The living it.Β  Ever to and toward a pointless death (again, another, also).Β  To be.Β  To be (as human).Β  To wish.Β  To wish for otherwise(s).Β  To IMAGINE.

As much or as often as possible.Β  Regardless of structure, import, complexity, complication or difficulty, even desire – BODILY – as organism ~ orgasm FEELS whole, full, exceptional.Β  Pain, lack, abuse, obtrusion, power, inequality, mystery, vanish, abandon…and yet… the body in orgasm is ecstatic – a weakening of consciousness, swoon, a likening unto death.Β  Ecriture.

Without meaning

Without import

Without portent

Without purpose

Try (again), ask for (fail again), achieve (fail better)

Anyway, anyhow, silence.

THERE IS ONLY SO MUCH TIME!

The rest go hang – come undone – fail, fall, try harder, wish, hope, imagine – make sense, sensibility, concept, meaning – IN ANY CASE: organism ~ orgasm – more pain and more pleasure will come, will follow upon, will remember, remain – time and consequence – a weakening, a swoon, a likening unto death.

Orga(ni)sm doesn’t care.Β  All impact an add-on.Β  Intellect / emotion / sensation / cognition / perception – derivative, invented – and yet – orgasm is an organismic moment.Β  La petite mort.Β  Ecriture.

Generative?Β  Reproducing (or not).Β  Informative (or not).Β  Act, study, behave (or not).Β  And then…NOT.Β  Organismic gathering toward totality for a moment.Β  There is living, there is dying (and death) and they (in fact) are indistinguishable.Β  This life.Β  The living it.Β  Ever to, in, toward pointless death (again, another, also).Β  To be.Β  To be (as human).Β  To wish.Β  To wish for otherwise(s).Β  To IMAGINE.Β  Being orgasmically.

To live.Β  To die.Β  (breathe out).

It is windy.

The Neutre Becoming : Untitled Writing

β€œthe writer must expose himself to his exteriority”

-William Brogan-

twombly_untitled

In the process of inscription, I am neutral.Β  Ambiguously being.Β  Neutered.

Existing via language that has not yet been written opens a sort of potential – possible becomings, as yet unknown, unidentified – possible positings of the impossible – WRITING enaction.Β  I am unspecified before the letters which commenceΒ demonstrating what / who / how as It (this human) encounters them – imagines, recalls, learns, selects, experiments and undoes, chooses and deletes.Β  Engaging with the sea.Β  With hearsay and learning, words read or perceived, borrowing, borrowing, sifting and hybridizing.

From wherever, therefore, whomever, toward knows-not-what…IN THE MIDST…WRITING: activity, action, attempt…Everything trying.

A human.Β  A person.Β  Acting.Β  Toward what ends? Β Perhaps to say.Β  To express.Β  To communicate.Β  To discover.Β  Invent.Β  Investigate.Β  Imagine.Β  To play. Β To die. Β Not to die.Β  Becoming / evincing / composing / traversing β€˜knows-not-what.’  Anything.Β  Nothing.Β  Living…to Death.

This is why.Β  This is why my own β€˜need-to-write.’  To become.Β  To try.Β  To live on.Β  To keep going.Β  Living toward, forward, into… perhaps.

Not-knowing I do not know.Β  At the edge, or a limit.Β  Searching a way.Β  To say.Β  To discover.Β  To hear.Β  To emerge.Β  Wanting to express, to find out, to dialogue – capable of expressing β€œVery little…almost nothing,”  I β€œtry again.Β  Fail again,” and hopefully (but β€œno matter”) β€œfail better.”

The internal urgency to write rather than speak, or to speak writing or even write speaking arising when I don’t know the words with which to.

β€˜The need to write is linked to the point at which nothing can be done with words.”

-Maurice Blanchot-

Selecting the pen, scribbling into the paper when there are no words (that I know) for that which (before words) I experience an urgency toward.

Therefore…working and playing – experiment and effort – name-changing and changeling – It commences.Β  Exploring.Β  Expeditions into letters and language.Β  Into sounds, mouths and breaths.Β  Into indeterminate dreams and dubious memories.Β  Desires and wishes and hopes.Β  To connect or converge.Β  To speak or hear back.Β  To know by finding out.Β  WRITING: to learn by failing.

β€œbecom[ing] the empty place where the impersonal affirmation emerges”

-Maurice Blanchot-

Melancholy (Lispector, Pessoa, Beckett, Jabes, Kafka, Blanchot?) and ecstatic (Rilke, Mallarme?, Holderlin, Nietzsche, Cixous?) human activity/task/capacity.Β  β€œNeed.”

β€œThat there is language.”

Begin.Β  Again.

at the point at which nothing can be done with words

***************************

I attempt to express the extent of my experience of love…

Endeavor to language particular beauty…

Strive to tell you how I… try to say…

Make effort to describe my children, the cheek/lip/ankle/voice/presence of my beloved, the eye contact and thought-contact of a friend, paw of a kitten, core of a concept, element of a scent, a breeze, a trace, a view…

Venture some new construction, a world, characters, possibilities…directions and directives…

Ache to communicate…

Will to connect…

Crave to continue…

WRITING: TO LEARN (something?) BY FAILING

perhaps

β€œthe attempt to open a space for the unsayable”

-maurice blanchot-

to fail…

Context for Alias Harlequin

from Michel Serres’Β Troubadour of Knowledge

Serres - TroubadourSerres - Troubadour 2Serres - Troubadour 22

Alias Harlequin – Identities

Picasso_Harlequin sketch

β€œTo recognize yourself in… To multiply your likenesses”

-Edmond Jabes

And what do you suppose it is to be a β€œNathan Wayne Filbert” human?Β  To be named?Β  Alias Harlequin?

What do you suppose it might be like to be β€œIda Sophia Lind Filbert”?Β  β€œJada Lynette Smith”?Β  β€œOliver Myshkin”?

β€œHallie Noel Linnebur”?

β€œTristan Rene Wells Filbert”?Β  β€œSimon H. Lilly”?Β  β€œAidan Stafford”?Β  β€œHerman Melville”?Β  β€œPaul Feyerabend”?Β  β€œRachel S. Como”?Β  β€œPaul O’Callahan”?Β  β€œMeghan Miller”?Β  β€œJim H. Charles?”  β€œWarren Charles Farha”?Β  β€œAmanda Marie Lind”?Β  β€œFernando Pessoa”?

A cow.Β  A particular cow – an Hereford – on a particular plot of land in Mitchell County, Kansas?

β€œPlato”?Β  β€œKathy Downes”?Β  β€œOrtho Stice”?Β  A Welsh Corgi β€œTippy”?Β  β€œNapoleon Bonaparte”?Β  β€œCharles S. Peirce”?Β  The clerk at the grocery store?Β  β€œChristopher Fynsk”?Β  That Forest Ranger?Β  A pet hamster β€œJacques”?Β  β€œClaudius”?Β 

WHY SHOULD ANY ONE HUMAN BE ANY MORE INTERESTING THAN ANOTHER?

WHY SHOULD ANY ONE ORGANISM BE ANY MORE INTERESTING THAN ANOTHER?

What means: β€œEFFECT”?

β€œWilliam Shakespeare”?Β  β€œAvital Ronell”?Β  β€œGod”?Β  β€œJohn Wayne Gacy”?Β  β€œHelena Bonham Carter”?Β  β€œMicrosoft”?Β  A caterpillar (be specific)?Β  β€œMahatma Ghandi”?Β  A sparrow?Β  Molecules composing particular dust?

WHAT IS?

how are we able to ask that question?

WHAT ARE WE?

how might we be β€œWHOs”?

Starting local:

What might it be like – as a β€œNathan Wayne Filbert” (Nobody) – to BE a β€œNathan Wayne Filbert” (A body)?

I’m not sure HOW to answer that.

β€œPerhaps writing means overcoming all resemblances within the very heart

of resemblance, being finally like yourself, like nothing.”

  • Edmond Jabes –

i.e. How that can be answered.

– WHO or WHAT answers – ?

WHAT MIGHT IT BE LIKE…TO BE?

(qualified to ANSWER)

can ANYthing β€œanswer”?

does β€œanswering” imply β€œlanguage”?

WHAT IS AN ANSWER?

(in relation to – ?)

What is(?) Nathan Wayne Filbert, Alias Harlequin?

IS β€œNathan Wayne Filbert”?

WHAT IS?

WHAT IS IS?

(how?)

WHAT IS A QUESTION? And WHY/HOW can a question be asked?

WHAT IS IT – are our – ideas?Β  – To β€œIMAGINE”?

what are ideas?

What might it be to β€œconceive”?

β€œto generate concepts” (D&G)

framings of our world-experience

[WHY?Β  HOW?

WHAT FOR?]

WHAT is a β€œperson”?Β  HOW?Β  WHY?Β  WHO?

Always and ever – HOW & WHY can we / do we ASK?

WHO QUESTIONS?

(WHAT)?

(HOW)?

Something begins

Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β  Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β  Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β  (in/with all this)

Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β  Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β  Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β Β  it would seem

(it seems)

it seems that something begins in/with questioning

Alias Harlequin, i.e.

– the one whom this effects, the one on whom this has effect, the one (same? No!) affected by him or her, by whom and it.Β  By this.Β  This.Β  That.Β  By Other, others, and therefore, Alias again, patchworked and quilted, becoming, undoing, altering.Β  Alias.

β€œPresumably most writers have many more ideas than they are able to act on”

– Ivan Vladislovic, The Loss Library –

Alias Harlequin – identities – is as is affected, effects, effected with/by.

Alias, i.e. as effected by β€œHallie Noel Linnebur”; as effected (generated?Β  Co-composed-with-) β€œPauline Margaret Kresin Filbert”; the St Bernard β€œZorro”; a specific train on a particular journey at a particular time; that mountain in that moment; Dec. 16, 1997 – a flu; and so on…

Alias – as situated in moments – e.g. β€œeach one.”  Harlequin – the human surname quilted with environment (micro-to-macro) in concourse.Β  β€œAlias” as the β€œname in shreds” – the fragmentary and provisional, pragmatically specifiable address.

Ambiguous and fluid (like β€œriver” itself – capable of designation but inconsistently contained) transient yet locatable, in form…perhaps.Β  Yet no.Β  β€œAlias” perhaps the medium (in-between) of morphing form and varying substance – what nothing also is (is not).

Name/term/signal/sign (β€œAlias”) as related to HNL, Dr. K, Dostoevsky, rustled grass, these sounds, this space-time and its company (surround) and then again, these again (but never β€œagain”) – designating β€œNOWs”.Β  Perhaps.Β  It depends.

What or Who, How β€œAlias Harlequin” ALWAYS depends on a totality of other dependencies, as it were (or is?)Β  β€œAs such.”

Alias Harlequin, representative?Β  Not that can of worms.Β  AND the β€œthing” itself? (network of momentary dependencies-in-relation)?

What might we call (it/him/etc.) then?Β  And what would β€œcalling” be/do – how?

WHO questions?

This Alias Harlequin.

β€œI am already so much the inscription of a divergence…What I was, if that could be described, was a whirlwind of tensions…”

Helene Cixous

β€œA word is binding and at the same time breaks our bonds.
To which of them shall I, one day, owe my freedom?”

β€œTo one only.Β  Your name in shreds.”

-Edmond Jabes, Book of Resemblances

 

“Machines alone have realized that sleep is no longer permitted”

Machine

β€œmachines alone have realized that sleep is no longer permitted”

– W. G. Sebald –

I haven’t slept.

Sometimes, in a dream, it feels like β€œit occurs to me.”

Trying to create a lesson plan for graduate students in the College of Education, I want to tell them why internet research / database searching / source evaluation seems so complex.Β  I take a hammer, a wrench, a tomahawk.Β  I bring a plow, a harness, a sewing machine.Β  I show a steam engine, a telegraph.Β  I think about them.

Hold them.Β  Turn them about.Β  Consider what you can do with them (if you know how).Β  Surmise what you can do with them (if you don’t know how).Β  Lots of things.

Humans devise stuff in concord with their environment.Β  Stones to stumble on, to throw, to hunt with, to pound.Β  Sticks to slap, clack, burn, poke.Β  Maybe carve.Β  Maybe paint.Β  Maybe write.

What we devise have certain rules, operations, constraints.Β  Remember the first time you wielded a hammer?Β  Learned to turn a doorknob?Β  Fitted a screwdriver to screw?

There’s a learning curve.Β  Adaptation.Β  Practice.Β  Change.

Try archery.Β  A piano.Β  Knit something.

Simple tools.Β  Fire.Β  Rock.Β  Wood.

Mud.Β  Sand.Β  Clay.

Try them.

So we figure out things that might be done with them.Β  Things to do, make, say, or think.Β  Certain things are more efficient.Β  Certain ways.Β  Certain hows.

We practice and experiment.Β  Devise.

I am 45.Β  Until I was in my teens, my fingers had not touched a lettered keyboard.Β  In high school I had a class for typing (on manual typewriters).Β  As a pianist I excelled.Β  My homework depended on the legibility of my handwriting through graduate school.Β  By 1993 there were computers in the β€œtyping room.”

You don’t have to know how to write now.

I watch the pencil or pen move along lined paper.Β  What do I have to know in order to do this?Β  How can I make the marks turn out like this?Β  Dexterity, control, care, effort.

Handwriting

Alphabetic literacy, knowledge, craft, semantics, semiotics, grammar and so forth…

Turn the hammer in your hand.Β  Tighten the wrench.Β  Use a pushpin. Take up a fork.Β  Operate a knife with steak.Β  Raise the glass.

β€œTools,” perhaps, technologies – technics and techniques – with their own sets of rules for our cognizant bodies.

Pull out your phone.Β  A swipe, some taps, a certain way of holding.Β  Understanding icons, visual literacies, kinetic craft, operational knowledge.Β  Know-how.Β  Complex.Β  Astounding.Β  Dexterous.Β  Intelligent.Β  Think of all the things you need to know to work that small device.

We devise.

And then adapt.

Diagram the innards of a personal computer, a Smartphone, a tablet, a scanner.Β  Imagine the adaptation required to operate that machine.

SOC

Think networked information.Β  Big Data.Β  If all our images, texts, conversations, correspondences, budgets, ledgers, laws, entertainments, plans, designs, models, experiments, applications, programs, art…(and so on) are DIGITAL / digitized… then algorithm’d and interfaced, softwared and connected… NONE OF US KNOW WHAT IS THERE.

The machines to which we dump, turn-over, DEVISE, inform, enTRUST – the artifacts of our living – because it is too much – no ONE (person or institution) catalogs, lists, calculates, organizes, arranges, assigns – THE MACHINES MUST DO IT BECAUSE OF THE SCALE and PACE…

NOBODY KNOWS WHAT IS THERE

Stacked algorithms and protocols select relevancy and value; similarity and related; significance and import; primacy and rank.Β  We operate.Β  And barely.Β  How do we guess the coding of its imputing?Β  How do we wrangle the keywords?Β  Information coming from anywhere at anytime into any port…what are the techniques, dexterity, knowledge, grammars, semantics, decoding, crafts – analytics?? – (at least as complex as the machine we diagrammed – times powers of 10 for all the machines involved!!) in order to locate our NEED; QUALITY; ESSENTIAL…?

In other words – we turn over.Β  We devise these concords of things – and revise ourselves according to them.

Internet_map_1024.jpg

Internet map

You’re guess may be as good as mine.Β  What is in there, where it is, and how to access it.Β  We use a Smartphone for many more things (at once) than a hammer or pen – while we and it are being used by systems larger than any of us altogether.

Systems of devised systems – we have no hope of controlling.Β  NONE of us.Β  Nor all of us.Β  We are entangled: mutually dependent – and subordinate.Β  We DON’T KNOW.Β  We DON’T KNOW.Β  We don’t know.Β  We’re IN the weather completely.

This is rough, when you also have a propensity, passion, or interest to know.Β  Subordinating oneself to a system is hard with a developed desire for autonomy, freedom, liberty.Β  As far as I know, at the mercy of was not a Sapient evolutionary goal.Β  Yet here we are.

How shall we adapt to these devices?

How shall we then live?